ScareMail - Scare.Me

The Yearlong Horror Experience Unavailable Anywhere Else

Delivered in 24 gripping letters over the course of a year, this immersive horror story will pull you into a world of suspense and terror, with a twist you'll never see coming.

Everything You Get:

  • Flexible Start Date (great for gifting)
  • 24 Captivating Letters, Delivered 2x a month.
  • More Than Just Letters: Includes 100+ eerie story artifacts, hidden lore, and more!
  • Join Thousands of Readers: 100,000+ letters sent to thrill-seekers like you.
"I'm only two letters in and I am hooked. I never thought I'd be so interested in a story being told through letters but I'm fascinated, I need to know what happens next! I would highly recommend this, either for yourself or as a gift." -Kyra ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Current Mailing Schedule

When you order your story today, please take note of the following mailing schedule.

  • Letter #1 mails within 1-3 business days* of purchase and include tracking(US)!
  • Remaining letters are mailed on the 2nd and 4th Friday of every month with free shipping!

US: Letters arrive in as little as a few days from the mailing date

International: Letters arrive in as little as a few days to a week from mailing date.

For a full list of mailing dates and mailing FAQs check out this page.

As the creator of Scaremail and writer of my stories, I stand behind my work and want you to have an enjoyable experience. If you are not happy with your purchase after the first two letters (or 30 days) I will issue you a full refund with no questions asked.

Scaremail is designed to be a cohesive story experience. Receiving every letter in order is important to me! Therefore, if a letter is missed, lost, stolen, or tattered just email me and I will happily resend the letter at no additional cost to you. 

Disabled Army Veteran, law enforcement veteran, author of 23+ novels and creator of Scaremail, David tries to connect with each and every reader by writing about the things he finds terrifying and interesting.

Q: Can I choose a start date?

A: Sure! And I'll try to time the mailing around your date. Just add a note to your order. Here's a card that explains the experience! Just print and fold!

Or, check out the Gift Box for a better gifting solution.

Q: Do you ship internationally?

A: Yes! We send mail all around the world.

Q: What if my letter doesn't arrive?

A: I have a generous 100% receipt policy. I will resend any letter that doesn't arrive within a timely manner so you can experience the entire story.

Q: Are these trackable?

A: Your first letter will include tracking(US). Subsequent letters will ship free but will not have tracking available.

Q: I am ordering this as a gift for someone that doesn't have internet access - can they still fully participate in Scaremail?

A: Yes! I do provide some additional content online for each story, but access to the internet is not required to participate in Scaremail.

Need to let someone know about their gift in the mail? Here's a Printable Gift Card. Just print, fold, and give/send it to them!

Q: I haven't subscribed yet? Am I too late?

A: No - you're not too late! I accept subscribers year-round. When you subscribe I'll start sending you the story from the beginning. You will continue to get the entire experience for the next 12 months.

Experience a New Way of Storytelling with Scaremail.

Get ready to embark on an unforgettable journey of horror with Scaremail! This unique concept of sharing terrifying tales through personal correspondence between characters offers a new way to experience the thrill of horror fiction.

It's gift-able. Immersive. And fun.

Receive Expertly Crafted Letters Every Month

  • Instead of spam or bills, readers will receive two letters a month for an entire year, mailed on the 2nd and 4th Friday of the month.
  • Each letter is meticulously written, crafted, and thoughtfully designed by Horror Author David Viergutz.
  • Includes eerie extras like unsettling photographs, ominous newspaper clippings, and cryptic symbols that turn a simple letter into an enhanced, storytelling experience.
  • Scaremail is doing away with bad news, bills, and junk mail. Now, you get to enjoy a haunted story a different way.

The Story

Michael, a curious and somewhat isolated individual, stumbled upon the mysterious website "Scare.Me" on an old, forgotten online forum. His interaction with the site has set off a series of psychological and supernatural events, tearing his life and mind apart. Now he feels compelled to share his experiences as a warning to the world.

Current Mailing Schedule

When you order your story today, please take note of the following mailing schedule.

  • Letter #1 mails within 1-3 business days* of purchase and includes First Letter Tracking(US).
  • Remaining letters are mailed on the 2nd and 4th Friday of every month

*Letters arrive in as little as a few days from the mailing date for US orders and 1-2 weeks for international orders.

Giftable!

Want to gift Scaremail to a loved one? Just use their shipping information at checkout or check out the Gift Box!

Get Immersed

Scaremail is meant to be explored. There is a story to be read, and every detail counts.

More Than letters

Scaremail is an experience. With your purchase you get free access to sCaremail, a unique and exclusive Penpal Service!

Double Veteran Owned

A Family Business

Over 150,000 sent and counting, Scaremail is mailed by Horror Author David Viergutz and his wife, Melissa. Both are disabled Army veterans and law enforcement veterans.

Customer Reviews

Based on 546 reviews
91%
(495)
7%
(38)
1%
(8)
0%
(1)
1%
(4)
E
Emily H.
Unsettling!

Scare Me mail is unsettling in the best way. It makes you feel goosebumps while also peaking your curiosity. I was very excited when I got it in the mail and was immediately immersed into the story as I opened each letter. I even showed my sister so we both could enjoy this unique way of storytelling. I definitely recommend this to anyone that wants to be immersed into a spooky but intriguing storyline! And I can't wait for the next letter!

W
Wendy T.
Love ScareMail!!!

Such an interest way to tell a story! Every letter peaks my interest more! I love how you connected with real-life situations! Totally can’t wait for my next letter to arrive! Thank you, David!

G
Greg F.
Loving it !

This is from my smoking hot girlfriend Stacey who is receiving the letters
“I freaking love it “

C
Chris B.
Amazing

The Scare.Me letter box is an absolute game-changer! I couldn't be happier with this purchase – it's an awesome addition that finally keeps my letters safe and secure. From the moment I ordered, the experience was fantastic. It arrived really fast, which was a pleasant surprise, and the condition was absolutely great, perfectly packaged.
This letter box is definitely worth getting to store your letters. The quality is top-notch, and it feels incredibly sturdy and reliable. But what really pushed this review over the top was the personal touch: it was awesome to see it signed, and finding some additional goodies inside was just the cherry on top. It made the unboxing experience truly special.
I wholeheartedly and enthusiastically recommend ordering from Scare.Me. You won't be disappointed!

J
J.S.
This was a gift

My daughter said she loved the presentation. I don’t know about the story yet.

A
Anonymous
Perfect gift!!

I sent to my friend for her birthday and she thought it was so awesome!! She hasn't figured out who sent it yet 😏

K
Katri A.
Wow

I just read the first letter. I want to devour next ones as soon as possible! The thing about snail mail, the anticipation, visiting the mail box every day.. Damn! It's been awhile since something has had me this excited!

m
michael g.
1st letter

I received my 1st letter and have read and re-read it over and over. It is very interesting and I cannot wait to recieve more. I think it is well written and I can absolutely see myself being drawn into this story. Great work David.

D
Dawn M.T.
"Best Gift Ever"

This was actually a gift for my daughter, but she absolutely LOVES it. She brought so I could check it out, and it's definitely awesome!! She is looking forward to the next one (and all those afterwards as well). My only regret it that I didn't order it for myself! The pen and letter opener are really neat too! Definitely FIVE stars!!! Here is my daughter with her special collector's box (which is already storing her first set of goodies). Thanks again!!!

#
#theheavymetalmom
Best Self Care Gift Ever!

I love horror, heavy metal, camping, concerts, blind boxes, surprises, Edward Lee books, vintage and....Scaremail. Hands down the best gift I've ever lifted myself...and my mom! Forever fan, #theheavymetalmom

Frequently Asked Questions

Sure! And I'll try to time the mailing around your date. Just add a note to your order. And don't forget to ask for a Scaremail Card that explains the experience so you don't have to!

Or, check out the Gift Box!

While I am certainly real, Michael is not. He and many other characters are based on people I know. Some of their proclivities and the things that make them unique are real too.

Yes! We send mail all around the world.

I have a generous 100% receipt policy. I will resend any letter that doesn't arrive within a timely manner so you can experience the entire story.

Yes! I do provide some additional content online for each story, but access to the internet is not required to participate in Scaremail.

Need to let someone know about their gift in the mail? Here's a Printable Gift Card. Just print, fold, and give/send it to them!

No - you're not too late! My model supports subscribers any time during the year. When you subscribe I'll start sending you the story you subscribed to. You will continue to get the entire experience for the next 12 months.

I use USPS First Class Mail and the delivery time varies up to 2 weeks domestically and up to 6 weeks internationally. A list of my shipping dates are listed here.

My general suggestion is 14+ but each child is different. Scaremail contains disturbing themes, imagery and descriptions. There is no abuse of any kind, child, animal or sexual. There is mild swearing. Minor drug and alcohol references.

Join 10,000+ Readers

Scaremail is shipped worldwide and new letters are mailed daily.

Want to gift Scaremail?

The Scaremail Giftbox is perfect for gifting. Your loved one can start the subscription when ready!