What Readers are saying

Based on 537 reviews
92%
(493)
6%
(32)
1%
(8)
0%
(1)
1%
(3)

I love it just the perfect goft

Excited to see what's next...

I purchased one for myself and one for my daughter. We both enjoy unusual games and books so thought we'd enjoy chatting through these as we get them. Loving it so far!

Awesome

I am enjoying this story so much. I love the story line and can't wait for my next letter

Bi-weekly horror letter

I got this for a friend who likes horror stuff, they said that they would rate you a 10 if they could. The website was not difficult to use, and it allowed for me to set this up for a friend without issue or difficulty. Let me know if you have any other questions.

Very addicting!!

I've only received two letters so far but it has me on my toes. I can't wait to see where this goes!!!

It's an awesome box for my creepy letters. It's also signed and included some great discounts to use, too. Great addition to my spooky bookshelves!

eagerly awaiting

I feel it is too early for me to give an accurate review. However, I can say that I eagerly await the mailings. I just got the 2nd one and it is definately grabbing my attention. 2 more weeks to wait....

Best gift

I bought this as a gift for my nephew who loves all things horror and Halloween. He loves it and is anxiously waiting for the next letter to arrive.

Definitely buying again. Such a riveting beginning i cant wait for the next one

Slow build - worth it!

I’m on my 5th letter and I’m starting to get creeped out and I KNOW it’s gonna get even worse (in a good way). These are awesome and a great gift for any horror fan. I love it so far! I saw someone else wanted to unsubscribe because they were too scared - now THAT’S a testimonial!!!

We’ve only received our first letter so far but we love it! I cannot wait to get our next letter 😍 this makes me look forward to checking the mail LOL

1st letter

I received my 1st letter and have read and re-read it over and over. It is very interesting and I cannot wait to recieve more. I think it is well written and I can absolutely see myself being drawn into this story. Great work David.

Wow !

Omg this so fun and scary! Love it so much !

Mysterious and Spooky Fun!

What a great idea reinvented in a new way. Pen pals takes on a whole new meaning! Thank You! I am thoroughly "hooked"! L💀💀

ScareMe already has me curious for more of the story. The mention of a Steven King book that I have previously read, is also intriguing. Waiting patiently fir the next mailing.

A++++

I am really enjoying this gift I received. Love the letter coming to me. Opening it always makes me a little excited. The story so far is really good and a bit unsettling. It is written really well and keeps me on the edge of my seat. Best gift I've gotten a long time.

The Scaremail Collectable Box - Scare.Me

Got this for someone for a birthday gift! Concept and items included in the letters are creative and interesting. I think there was a page missing from one of the letter packets but otherwise it’s been enjoyed thoroughly by the recipient! Super fun gifting idea!

Love, love, love

I absolutely love the whole aesthetic and overall idea of SCAREMAIL. Being a person who loves spooky things these letters. Only on my second letter and I am absolutely hooked!!! Love this!!!

This gives me something fun to look forward to every month I love them!

Scare Mail

I didn't think I would like it, but I'm hooked and waiting for the next letter.

I just got my first one in the mail. Its mostly introduction and whatnot but thats how books and movies start. I’m excited to see where things go and how scary it might get. A few of my friends are skeptical so theyre waiting to see what i say before they subscribe as well.

Amazing

I love story telling through snail mail. It's not common and very interesting. Also love the little tidbit facts that come with each letter. I look forward to the next one each time!!

Mr%20Wicker

I%20loved%20this%20story.%20It%20was%20very%20captivating%20I%20couldn%E2%80%99t%20put%20it%20down.%20Finished%20it%20too%20fast.%20Lol

Very nice! I cant wait to get my next letter!